Toilets are one of those things you don’t think about until they stop working right.
We get it. Nobody dreams of replacing a toilet. But if yours is showing signs of age (or getting crusty with white buildup you can’t scrub off), it might be time to consider an upgrade.
At Ackerman Plumbing, we’ve seen toilets from every decade, and we’ve got a good sense of when they’re worth fixing… and when they’re just plain tired.
Let’s talk calcium buildup, toilet lifespan, and when it’s time to retire your toilet.
So, How Long Should a Toilet Last?
Most toilets last 25–50 years, depending on the quality of the model and how well it’s been maintained. That said, plumbing fixtures don’t age like fine wine.
Even if your toilet still flushes, an older one may:
- Use way more water than modern toilets
- Be prone to leaks or hairline cracks
- Have worn-out parts that constantly need replacing
- Show stubborn mineral buildup you can’t scrub away
Just because it still works doesn’t mean it’s working well.
What Is That White Buildup?
That crusty white stuff you see around the rim or in the tank is calcium and lime buildup—a result of hard water. Over time, it can:
- Clog the tiny jet holes under the toilet rim (leading to weak or uneven flushes)
- Make your toilet look permanently dirty, even when it’s clean
- Affect the moving parts in your tank, like the flapper and fill valve
If you’ve got hard water in your area (hello Tiffin), this is super common.
Can You Clean It Off?
To a point, yes. Vinegar, a pumice stone, or hard water cleaners can help. But once buildup hardens or starts messing with your flush, it’s usually more than just a cosmetic problem.
If you’re scrubbing until your arms fall off and your toilet still looks like it’s been through a calcium snowstorm, it might be time to move on.
Signs Your Toilet Is Just... Old
You might want to consider a replacement if:
- It's 20+ years old and needs frequent repairs
- You see hairline cracks around the base or tank
- It's stained, discolored, or has mineral buildup that won’t budge
- The flush is weak, sluggish, or inconsistent
- It’s a water hog (older models can use up to 6 gallons per flush!)
Modern toilets use as little as 1.28 gallons per flush which adds up to serious savings over time.
Is It Worth Replacing?
Absolutely! Especially if:
- You’ve already replaced internal parts multiple times
- You’re upgrading your bathroom
- You’re tired of the constant scrubbing and maintenance
A new toilet is a relatively affordable upgrade that can save you water, improve your bathroom’s appearance, and help you avoid surprise leaks or cracks.
Not Sure How Old Yours Is?
Here’s a quick tip: Look inside the tank, on the back wall or underside of the lid. Most toilets have a date stamp.
Want a Pro Opinion?
If your toilet’s showing calcium buildup, we’ll help you figure out the smartest next step (and install a shiny new one if you’re ready).
Ready for a Cleaner, More Efficient Toilet?
We can help you ditch the stains and start fresh. Call us or schedule service online; your bathroom deserves it.